Pizza My Heart Menu California: Prices, Slices & Full Guide
A slice of pizza is one of the easiest meals to work into a California coast day, and Pizza My Heart is built around that idea: oversized slices, surf-inspired pizza names, and whole pies to share. If you’re checking the Pizza My Heart Menu California before ordering, the key numbers are simple: published slices run 5.50–6.75, basic whole cheese pizzas start at $19.50, and many 18-inch specialty pizzas cost $41.
I’m Vanessa, the California dining researcher behind CA Travel Times. For this guide, I checked Pizza My Heart’s published menu against the ordering sources rather than treating one delivery listing as a statewide price list. These are published menu prices, not a receipt from a personal visit. Your chosen store’s checkout total may differ, particularly after taxes, delivery fees, or location-specific changes.
Pizza My Heart Prices at a Glance
| What you’re ordering | Published price | What to know |
| Oversized cheese slice | $5.50 | Lowest-listed slice price |
| Pepperoni or pesto slice | $6.00 | Quick individual meal |
| Selected loaded slices | $6.75 | Includes Big Sur and Super Veggie |
| 12-inch cheese pizza | $19.50 | Base build-your-own pie |
| 14-inch cheese pizza | $23.50 | Middle size |
| 18-inch cheese pizza | $29.00 | Large pie with eight big slices |
| 12-inch specialty pizza | 22.50–25.50 | Depends on recipe; Manresa is $24 |
| 18-inch specialty pizza | 35.00–41.00 | Depends on recipe; Manresa is $38 |
| Regular salad | 7.75–9.75 | Classic Caesar is $9 |
| Six wings | $10.99 | Bone-in or boneless |
| Bread Stix | $8.50 | With mozzarella: $10.50 |
| Shareable dessert | $7.50 | Kook-ie or Cinna-Bomb |
Price note: Amounts in the tables below come from Pizza My Heart’s public website as checked on October 19, 2026. They are reference prices, not guarantees at every branch. Capitola Village and Valley Fair Mall specifically have limited menus. Check the official menu before ordering.
Start with a Slice: The Individual Pizza Menu
Pizza by the slice is the straightforward choice when you’re eating alone or don’t want leftovers. Pizza My Heart publishes nine slice varieties, divided between meat and meat-free options.
| Slice | Price | Main ingredients |
| Cheese | $5.50 | Tomato sauce and California mozzarella |
| Old-School Pepperoni | $6.00 | Pepperoni and cheese |
| Pesto | $6.00 | Basil, garlic, almonds and Parmesan |
| Manresa | $6.00 | Basil, garlic, tomato and ricotta |
| Big Sur | $6.75 | Pepperoni, sausage, portobello, roasted garlic, green onion |
| D’Lex Chicken & Bacon | $6.75 | Chicken, bacon, mushrooms, green onion, creamy garlic sauce |
| Maui Wowie | $6.75 | Canadian bacon and pineapple |
| Pepperoni & Sausage | $6.75 | Two classic meat toppings |
| Super Veggie | $6.75 | Tomato, mushrooms, onion, olives, bell peppers, artichokes |
My ordering takeaway: Cheese is the cheapest entry point. Big Sur is the better choice if you want to try the chain’s signature combination without buying a whole pizza. Pesto contains almonds and dairy, so don’t assume a meat-free slice is nut-free or vegan.
The official site says slices are available daily in restaurants and may be added for delivery with full-size pizza orders. It also advertises a free slice with an in-restaurant T-shirt purchase; confirm the offer at the store before relying on it.
Whole Pizza Prices: Every Specialty Pie
The main Pizza My Heart Menu California selection is built around three whole-pie diameters: 12, 14 and 18 inches. Instead of repeating the same pies in an awards table and a meat table, I’ve grouped each unique recipe once. Prices below refer to standard published preparations.
Meat and Chicken Specialty Pizzas
| Pizza | 12-inch | 14-inch | 18-inch | Flavor profile |
| Big Sur | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Pepperoni, sausage, portobello, roasted garlic, green onion |
| Maui Wowie | $22.50 | $28.50 | $35.00 | Canadian bacon and pineapple |
| Cowell’s Combo | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Pepperoni, sausage, olives, mushrooms, onions, peppers |
| Maverick’s | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, Canadian bacon |
| Sunset Beach | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Canadian bacon, bacon, onions, peppers, pineapple |
| Davenport | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Sausage, spinach, garlic, mushrooms, onion |
| Doheny Sweet Heat | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Pepperoni, sausage, pickled peppers, ricotta, hot honey |
| Wingnut’s | $22.50 | $28.50 | $35.00 | Pepperoni, onions, mushrooms |
| D’Lex Chicken & Bacon | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Chicken, bacon, mushrooms, garlic, green onion, white sauce |
| Watsonville Apple | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Apple, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, green onion, Gorgonzola |
| Rockaway | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | BBQ chicken, red onion, cilantro |
| Fort Point | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Chicken, sausage, pesto, ricotta, tomato, artichoke, herbs |
| Depot Hill | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Chicken, sun-dried tomatoes, pesto |
| Pleasure Point | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Chicken, garlic, tomato and spinach |
Which should you choose? Big Sur is the house signature and the safest starting point for a first order if you like meat and garlic. For sweet and savory flavors, try Watsonville Apple or Doheny Sweet Heat. Maui Wowie and Wingnut’s sit in a lower specialty price tier.
Pizza My Heart highlights past competition awards for Big Sur, Watsonville Apple and Fort Point. Awards describe the restaurant’s history, not independent proof that one flavor will suit every diner.
Vegetarian and Vegan Specialty Pizzas
| Pizza | 12-inch | 14-inch | 18-inch | Key ingredients |
| Manresa | $24.00 | $31.00 | $38.00 | Basil, garlic, Roma tomatoes, ricotta |
| Pesto | $22.50 | $28.50 | $35.00 | Basil, garlic, Parmesan, almonds |
| Mt. Diablo (vegan) | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Plant-based cheese, Beyond Meat sausage, mushrooms, peppers |
| Little Sur | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Roasted garlic, peppers, portobello, tomato, herbs |
| Prima | $22.50 | $28.50 | $35.00 | Tomato, feta, olives, Parmesan |
| The Hook | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Tomato, olives, peppers, mushrooms, artichokes, onion, Parmesan |
| Castroville | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Almond-basil pesto, spinach, artichoke, tomatoes, feta |
| Vegan Big Sur | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Vegan pepperoni, plant-based sausage, portobello, roasted garlic |
| Linda Mar | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Spinach, garlic, artichokes, broccoli, olives, tomato |
| Virgin Creek | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Basil, garlic, ricotta, Roma tomato |
| The Mendocino (vegan) | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 | Plant-based cheese, tomato, garlic, breadcrumbs, basil |
Vegan versus vegetarian matters here. Pizza My Heart explicitly identifies Mt. Diablo, Vegan Big Sur and The Mendocino as vegan. The other meat-free recipes may contain dairy, including ricotta, feta or Parmesan. The restaurant offers plant-based mozzarella substitution on pizzas, but says it is not available at Valley Fair Mall or Capitola Village.
Build Your Own Pizza: What Each Extra Topping Costs
Want a standard pepperoni pie or a precise combination? The design-your-own menu prices pizzas by the number of toppings, rather than advertising one flat fee for all add-ons.
| Build-your-own option | 12-inch | 14-inch | 18-inch |
| Cheese only | $19.50 | $23.50 | $29.00 |
| 1 topping | $21.00 | $26.00 | $32.00 |
| 2 toppings | $22.50 | $28.50 | $35.00 |
| 3 toppings | $24.00 | $31.00 | $38.00 |
| 4 toppings | $25.50 | $33.50 | $41.00 |
Regular topping choices include pepperoni, sausage, bacon, anchovies, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, spinach, olives, broccoli, pineapple and other vegetables. Certain premium ingredients count as two toppings, including chicken, pesto, portobello mushrooms, roasted garlic cloves, Gorgonzola, figs and roasted red peppers. The online menu also lists plant-based vegan pepperoni in the two-topping category.
For a basic pie, going from a 12-inch cheese pizza to a 12-inch four-topping pizza raises the menu price by $6. Always review the final price before confirming a customized order, especially for combinations beyond the published four-topping tiers. If you prefer thick, deep-dish pizza instead of this thinner coastal style, compare the sizes and prices in our BJ’s Restaurant Menu California guide.
A Heart-Shaped Pizza Option
A 14-inch heart-shaped pizza with two toppings is listed for $29.75. It’s a fun alternative for a birthday, anniversary or Valentine’s meal, but check its availability at your chosen branch before planning around it.
Sides, Wings, Salads and Desserts
Pizza My Heart isn’t a broad pasta-and-burger restaurant. The verified main menu concentrates on pizza, a smaller group of savory sides, salads and two shareable sweets.
Wings and Bread
| Item | Portion | Listed price |
| Traditional chicken wings | 6 | $10.99 |
| Traditional chicken wings | 12 | $17.99 |
| Traditional chicken wings | 24 | $29.99 |
| Boneless chicken wings | 6 | $10.99 |
| Boneless chicken wings | 12 | $17.99 |
| Boneless chicken wings | 24 | $29.99 |
| Bread Stix | Standard order | $8.50 |
| Bread Stix with mozzarella | Standard order | $10.50 |
Wings are listed with Buffalo or BBQ sauce. The menu says ranch or blue cheese is available on request. Bread Stix feature garlic, olive oil and Parmesan and can be paired with ranch or pizza sauce.
Regular and Group Salads
| Salad | Regular | Large (serves 8–10) |
| Classic Caesar | $9.00 | $50.00 |
| Classic Caesar with chicken | $9.75 | $57.50 |
| Greek | $7.75 | $42.50 |
| Seasonal Greens | $7.75 | $42.50 |
| Chicken Walnut | $9.75 | $57.50 |
The Greek salad brings olives, feta and artichokes; Seasonal Greens includes mixed greens and crunchy vegetables. The Chicken Walnut salad adds chicken, candied walnuts and Gorgonzola. Caesar dressing contains anchovy, so it isn’t suitable for someone avoiding fish. If a salad or sandwich is your main lunch plan rather than a side to pizza, our Mendocino Farms Menu California guide compares more of those options.
Something Sweet
| Dessert | Listed price | Description |
| Kook-ie | $7.50 | Oversized chocolate-chip cookie, portioned for sharing |
| Cinna-Bomb | $7.50 | Baked cinnamon-spiced dough with icing |
Cinna-Bomb contains milk ingredients according to Pizza My Heart’s dietary information. These desserts make more sense as a group add-on than as an individual budget meal.
Drinks: Published Beverage Prices
| Drink | Price |
| Fountain soda | $3.00 |
| 20-ounce bottled soda | $3.25 |
| 2% or chocolate milk | $3.00 |
| Apple juice | $3.00 |
| Bottled water / listed vitamin water | $3.00 |
| Mexican soft drink | Usually $3.25; specific Coke and Sprite entries list $3.00 |
| Craft beer | Price not published consistently |
Drink selections differ by branch. The company notes that regional soda taxes can affect prices. Craft beer, where available, rotates by location, so I haven’t assigned it an invented statewide price.
Is Pizza My Heart Expensive? Three Sample Orders
Use these menu-price examples before tax and fees to see what different orders add up to. They are arithmetic examples, not advertised combos or discounts.
| Meal plan | Example order | Food subtotal |
| Budget solo lunch | Cheese slice + fountain soda | $8.50 |
| More filling slice stop | Big Sur slice + Caesar salad | $15.75 |
| Two people sharing | 14-inch two-topping pie + Bread Stix | $37.00 |
| Simple group pizza | Two 18-inch cheese pizzas | $58.00 |
| Specialty group pizza | Two 18-inch Big Sur pizzas | $82.00 |
Best-value angle: A slice makes sense if you’re dining alone. For a group, compare whole pies before purchasing multiple individual slices. Two 18-inch cheese pizzas cost $58 on the posted menu and provide 16 large slices in total. How far that goes depends on appetite, sides and whether guests eat meat or dairy. For a different sit-down meal with burgers, fries or tacos, see our Islands Restaurant Menu California price guide before deciding where to eat.
Gluten-Free, Vegan and Allergy Details You Should Check
Dietary labels need more care than price tables. Pizza My Heart offers a rice-flour gluten-free crust for 12-inch pizzas on request, but states plainly that it cannot guarantee any restaurant item is 100% gluten-free because flour from regular pizza production can spread through the kitchen. A gluten-free crust is not a promise of celiac-safe preparation.
| Dietary consideration | Useful menu detail | Important limitation |
| Vegan | Mt. Diablo, Vegan Big Sur, The Mendocino; vegan pizza dough | Confirm substitutions and shared-kitchen contact |
| Vegetarian | Manresa, Little Sur, Prima, The Hook and others | Some include dairy; Caesar contains anchovy |
| Gluten-free crust | Rice-flour crust for 12-inch pizzas | Cross-contact cannot be ruled out |
| Tree nuts | Pesto is made with almonds; Chicken Walnut has walnuts | Ask about preparation and shared equipment |
| Legumes | Vegan pepperoni includes pea protein | Relevant to legume allergies |
| Dairy-free | Standard dough contains no dairy | Cheese and many toppings/sauces do contain dairy |
The restaurant states that its regular dough has no eggs, dairy or soy. That does not make a finished cheese pizza vegan. Before ordering for a serious allergy, consult the official Pizza My Heart dietary information and speak with the location directly.
For nutrition figures such as calories and sodium, use the restaurant’s nutrition and allergen resources. Exact values depend on the pie, size and toppings; no general calorie figure is reliable for every combination.
Where to Order in California
Pizza My Heart operates in Northern California, including the Santa Cruz/Monterey area, Silicon Valley, the Peninsula and East Bay. It is not a statewide chain with a store in every California city. Find your nearest branch through the official location finder.
Selected locations listed by the company include:
| Location | Address | Published typical hours |
| Aptos / Pizza 1 | 253 Center Avenue, Aptos | Sun–Thu 11 a.m.–9 p.m.; Fri–Sat 11 a.m.–10 p.m. |
| Burlingame | 235 Primrose Road, Burlingame | Sun–Thu 11 a.m.–9 p.m.; Fri–Sat 11 a.m.–10 p.m. |
| Capitola 41st Avenue | 2180 41st Avenue, Capitola | Sun–Thu 11 a.m.–10 p.m.; Fri–Sat 11 a.m.–11 p.m. |
| Capitola Village | 209 Esplanade, Capitola | Sun–Thu 11 a.m.–9 p.m.; Fri–Sat 11 a.m.–10 p.m. |
| Cupertino | 19409 Stevens Creek Boulevard, Cupertino | Sun–Thu 11 a.m.–9 p.m.; Fri–Sat 11 a.m.–10 p.m. |
| Dublin | 7281 Amador Plaza Road, Dublin | Sun–Thu 11 a.m.–9 p.m.; Fri–Sat 11 a.m.–10 p.m. |
Watch for branch exceptions: Capitola Village is marked takeout only by the company, and both Capitola Village and Valley Fair Mall have limited menus. Opening hours and fulfillment options can change; check the specific location before traveling.
If you’re exploring California neighborhoods beyond this stop, the California Local Guides collection is a place to plan other food and sightseeing stops.
Pickup vs. Delivery: Why Your Checkout May Cost More
Pizza My Heart’s official online ordering page lets you choose a participating location. Delivery marketplaces can display different item prices, service fees and availability.
For example, the DoorDash competitor menu I checked showed a cheese slice from $6.05, compared with $5.50 on Pizza My Heart’s published menu. It also showed a Big Sur slice from $7.43, versus the official $6.75. These are examples from a marketplace listing, not a fixed surcharge guaranteed at every store.
A supplied Uber Eats page for a Santa Clara location at 4300 Great America Parkway says that particular storefront has been closed on Uber Eats since February 29, 2024. That doesn’t establish the availability of other Pizza My Heart branches on Uber Eats. Enter your address and check your actual store instead.
My practical order-check sequence is to select the correct branch, verify that the desired pizza and crust are offered, compare food subtotals, and then inspect taxes, fees and delivery estimates before paying. A displayed item price alone is not the final total.
Ordering for a Party or Office
The company’s large-orders page offers pizza bundles booked directly with Pizza My Heart; it says these particular deals are not available through DoorDash or EZ Cater. Bundle rates depend on the selected store and order, so the public information doesn’t support a universal catering-price table.
For planning, Pizza My Heart says its 18-inch pizza has eight large slices. Its suggested starting points are about two slices per active adult with a large appetite, 1.5 slices per other adult or teen, and one slice per child aged 12 or under. Those guidelines are especially useful for office and team orders; add a buffer when pizza is the only food.
The company also offers a pizza calculator designed mainly for gatherings of 40 or more. Large salads serve approximately eight to ten people. Confirm serving needs and any dietary restrictions with the restaurant before placing a large order.
Promotions and Rewards: What Is Actually Confirmed?
The official menu advertises one free slice when you buy a Pizza My Heart T-shirt in a restaurant. That’s a promotion tied to a merchandise purchase, not a blanket free-slice offer.
The company’s rewards page says it has been working on a points-based program and invites customers to join its mailing list for launch information. I could not verify a universal, currently active points-to-dollars earning rate or reliable statewide happy-hour schedule. Rather than promise an unconfirmed deal, check the official promotions page and your local checkout for live offers.
Bottom Line: What I’d Order for the Budget
For a quick stop, the $5.50 cheese slice or $6.75 Big Sur slice gives the clearest way to sample Pizza My Heart without paying for an entire pie. For several diners, the 18-inch cheese pizza at $29 is the simplest published starting price, while Maui Wowie or Wingnut’s at $35 are lower-priced specialty choices compared with the $41 tier.
Use this guide to shortlist your food, then confirm the exact branch’s selection and final checkout total. That extra check matters more than any statewide-looking menu graphic, particularly when a limited-menu location or third-party delivery service is involved.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest pizza at Pizza My Heart?
The cheapest published single slice is cheese at $5.50. For whole pies, the 12-inch cheese pizza is listed at $19.50 before tax and optional extras.
How much is a large Big Sur pizza?
The 18-inch Big Sur costs $41 on the restaurant’s posted menu. The 12-inch version is $25.50 and the 14-inch version is $33.50.
Does Pizza My Heart sell pizza by the slice?
Yes. The official menu lists oversized slices including cheese, pepperoni, pesto, Big Sur, D’Lex Chicken & Bacon, Maui Wowie and Super Veggie. Individual slices cost 5.50–6.75 on the published menu.
Does Pizza My Heart have vegan pizza?
Yes. Mt. Diablo, Vegan Big Sur and The Mendocino are labeled vegan on the menu. Plant-based mozzarella may also be used on other pizzas, except at locations where that substitution is unavailable.
Can I order a gluten-free pizza?
The restaurant advertises a 12-inch rice-flour gluten-free crust upon request. It also warns that shared-kitchen flour exposure means food cannot be guaranteed completely gluten-free.
How many slices are in an 18-inch pizza?
Pizza My Heart states that an 18-inch large pizza has eight big slices. Its group-order recommendations vary by appetite and age.
Are the Pizza My Heart Menu California prices the same on DoorDash?
Not necessarily. The delivery listing reviewed showed higher starting prices for some slices than the official published menu. Always check the branch-specific ordering screen and final fees.
Does every store have the full pizza selection?
No. Pizza My Heart specifically identifies Capitola Village and Valley Fair Mall as having limited menus. Vegan cheese is also unavailable at those two locations according to the company’s customization guidance.
